How Social Media Affects Mental Health

Scroll to explore
HIPPA logo
HIPAA
Compliant

In the city of Long Beach, California – where bonmente’s physical practice is located – and cities across the globe, social media has become an integral part of many people’s daily lives. 

Billions of daily or monthly active users scroll through various social networking sites. 

Social media is a relatively new phenomenon, and researchers are still exploring its impact on mental health. Many of its effects remain unclear. Current research focuses on how social media may negatively affect individuals and families. Researchers are particularly interested in people with a history of mental health conditions, such as depression.

However, researchers began studying cyberpsychology long before Facebook existed. This field explores the psychological effects of internet use. In fact, cyberpsychology research predates even Facebook’s early days, when the platform was still called “TheFacebook.”

Since the early days of the Internet, researchers have explored its potential effects on mental health. Psychologists and mental health professionals, including psychiatrists, have long expressed concerns about the possible negative impact of spending time online.

Increasingly, it has become a problem for mental health professionals with patients whose mental health struggles are exacerbated by using social media. In some cases, the use of social media even contributes to the development of mental health issues in patients. 

For example, an issue that researchers frequently point to is the link between photo-heavy platforms and the development or intensification of body-image issues and eating disorders. 

For social media users based in certain parts of the United States (specifically, California and Florida) and struggling with mental health issues potentially linked to social media usage, bonmente can help.

The Rise of Social Media – and Its Impact on Mental Health 

How Social Media Affects Mental Health

The psychological impact of self-objectification and social comparison via media content posted online (e.g., meticulously composed Instagram selfies), along with concepts like the online disinhibition effect, have been research interests long before “Instagram” was “Burbn,” the photo-sharing app for pics of whiskey and bourbon that got retooled into the world’s premiere photo-sharing platform. 

What is significant about social media in particular is that it brought a wide swath of the population online for longer periods, and more consistently. This widened exposure to the above-named phenomena that cyberpsychology researchers study. 

In 2024, over five billion people were using social media. That is more than half of the worldwide human population. 

Consider that in 1995, only 14% of people used the Internet. By 2015, only 13% of people did not use the Internet in some capacity. 

Since 2012, the average user of social media consistently spends more than 90 minutes a day on social media, and more recently the amount is between two and two-and-a-half hours. 

Whereas in 1997, fewer internet users existed, with heavy users often engaging in niche topic forums. 

Such users would go online to discuss some obscure television show or video game that few people in their offline lives knew or cared about. But the “offline” connections were still there to discuss things like the latest news or everyday stressors. 

In contrast to those niche-interest websites, social media is more like an “everything store” for online conversation—the Wal-Mart of online discourse, if you will. Everything from major world events to small local happenings is a topic of conversation on platforms like Facebook. 

Hence, the appeal of social media to users. Online or not, it’s important to understand social media’s potential impact on mental health.

Unpacking the Mental Health Impact

Potentially Addicting?

The potential that social media can be addicting is a topic of study for researchers, and an idea that is familiar to many people in the public. 

Though a number of psychologists and mental health professionals are wary of claiming that social media can be inherently addicting, the widespread conversation about the potential for addiction is notable. 

Researchers have pointed to the concept of “intermittent rewards” for explaining why social media can be addicting. 

Researchers compare social media scrolling to playing a slot machine. Just as gamblers hope for occasional rewards, social media users scroll through feeds seeking something worthwhile. These rewards might include entertaining videos, useful information, or content that feels personally relevant. The possibility of finding something rewarding encourages users to keep scrolling.

The crux of the slot-machine analogy is that the user cannot predict when a reward may come. Hence, the motivation to keep scrolling, and keep returning to the platforms, in the hope of getting a reward.

Addiction in itself can be a major mental health issue. People can lose social connections, money, lots of time, and overall mental functioning, among other things, to an addiction. 

Some researchers question whether “addiction” accurately describes excessive internet use. They suggest “problematic use” as a more appropriate term. Regardless of the terminology, unhealthy social media habits can contribute to or worsen mental health problems.

Even if you would not consider yourself to have a problematic relationship to social media, there are some research-backed aspects of internet usage that are relevant to using social media in general. 

Media Overload, Negative Emotions, and Algorithmic Boosting of Negative Content

Blog on How Social Media Affects Mental Health

Mental health professionals have been noting how negative emotions like stress have a link to “media overload.” That can involve seeing an abundance of, for example, troubling news headlines about things like violent crime and injustice and war and environmental problems. 

The content-selecting algorithms on social media that shape our feeds generally select content based on engagement, rather than whether it would make a user feel positive. 

That is part of the reason why a typical scroll through a social media feed will feature a mix of “positive” and “negative” posts. Cute cat pictures with tens of thousands of “likes” will be sandwiched between massively controversial posts with a flood of high-emotion comments. 

Social media marketing is also based on user data, leading to more effective ads, which could potentially exacerbate impulse buying for those who struggle with that.

The targeted audience to witness these online social interactions depends on the audience members’ engagement with other posts. The algorithms bring you more of what you are likely to see, whether that is posts about physical activity’s impact on heart diseases or just pictures of cats.

That also partly explains why users of Meta platforms (Facebook and Instagram, largely) would keep seeing content that encouraged self-harm and disordered eating, even as workers at Meta were aware of this issue, as exposed in a Wall Street Journal report. 

Social Comparison and Low Self-Esteem

Social comparison involves evaluating oneself against others, whether physically or mentally. This behavior is common among humans, although the frequency and intensity vary from person to person. So, social comparison in itself is perfectly natural, as it can be a means for learning about the environment, other people, and oneself. 

Social media facilitates social comparison by providing a given user with a constantly replenishing bounty of information about other people, some of whom the user may know “IRL” (i.e., in real life). 

The problem here is that on social media, users constantly expose themselves to highlight reels of others’ lives, selected by the very people featured in the highlight reel. People of all age groups share content on online platforms like social media apps. Young people are especially vulnerable, but social media usage can involve social comparison for all users.

It would be fair to suggest that a good deal of these posts are self-flattering for the user, even in an unconventional way. For instance, a seemingly casual, ill-lit, even “ugly” selfie of someone may really serve to make the person in the photo appear to have the praiseworthy quality of not caring deeply about superficial appearances. 

This perpetual exposure to other people’s “best of” compilations, which may consist of everything from flattering photos to funny comments to moral or political commentary (some posts manage to combine all that and more) is really not what our social-comparison mental faculty, primal and genetically inherited from ancestors, was designed to withstand. 

Overall, social media can be an engine that helps drive low self-esteem in individuals. 

Social Comparison’s Tie-in to Self-objectification on Social Media

Information on How Social Media Affects Mental Health

What’s especially productive of mentally unhealthy social comparison is that the self-objectification phenomenon observed in cyberpsychology can lead to the false impression in users of social media that they are comparing themselves to other people, rather than media objects of or made by other people. 

From “Self-Objectification and Cognitive Performance: A Systematic Review of the Literature”, a research paper published in Frontiers in Psychology, here is a quick overview of the concept of self-objectification:

While self-objectification is often narrowly defined as the adoption of a third-person perspective on the body, the originators of objectification theory define self-objectification as occurring when individuals “treat themselves as objects to be looked at and evaluated” (Fredrickson and Roberts, 1997, p. 177; italics added).

According to this definition, the adoption of a third-person perspective on the body is a necessary but not sufficient condition for self-objectification. In addition to the perspectival shift from first-person to third-person, self-objectification requires the adoption of an evaluative, appearance-based self-construal.

To evaluate media objects made by other people, under the impression that those media objects can fitfully stand in for other people, not only encourages one to objectify others, but objectify oneself. (“How good can I look in a photograph?”) 

In the realm of body image, comparing one’s physical features to others’ photos can lead to low self-esteem. These photos are often media objects featuring digital representations of others, selected and sometimes edited by the poster.

Researchers have extensively studied the relationship between social media use and body-image concerns. Studies have explored links to body dysmorphia and eating disorders, particularly among adolescents. This research highlights concerns about how social media may influence body image and contribute to unhealthy attitudes toward appearance and eating habits.

Arguably, this extends beyond physical characteristics as well. 

Self-perception Could Be Affected by More than Just Photos

The asynchronous feature of computer-mediated communication allows people to take their time in composing and drafting captions, comments, and text posts. Online, you generally don’t need to answer or share information in real time. 

As a result, people have greater control over what they communicate online. They can carefully choose and edit the content they share before others see it. This differs from real-life conversations, where people exchange thoughts and reactions in real time. Online communication allows individuals to shape how others interpret their words, images, and other shared content.

As a result, people can carefully craft comments and captions that highlight their best qualities. This allows them to appear smarter, funnier, or more insightful than they might during spontaneous face-to-face conversations.

Think about how you respond to posts online. You might see something interesting but take time to draft a thoughtful reply. Sometimes, you may even step away before returning to finish your response. In face-to-face conversations, however, suddenly going silent or walking away mid-conversation would seem unusual.

Comparing yourself to others on social media can negatively affect your self-image. Posts focused on physical appearance may contribute to body-image concerns and feelings of inadequacy. Similarly, seeing others appear smarter, funnier, or more successful can create feelings of social inferiority.

Think of how many users are on social media, and therefore how many posts are there for social comparison. How many “people” (media objects) there are to social-compare with. 

The Online Disinhibition Effect and Issues with Emotional Regulation

Article on How Social Media Affects Mental Health

Why Face-to-Face Interactions Discourage Conflict

In real life, most people remain civil toward strangers because confrontations can have unpredictable consequences. You never know how someone might react to hostility or disagreement, and even walking away may not prevent further conflict.

However, avoiding confrontation isn’t always about physical safety. The possibility of awkward silence, embarrassment, or tension can also discourage people from engaging in arguments.

These potential consequences encourage people to approach face-to-face interactions with greater caution and consideration, even when disagreements arise.

The Online Disinhibition Effect

Why People Feel Safer Expressing Themselves Online

Online, the idea that conflict could lead to something potentially uncomfortable or even dangerous is less of a worry, because you can post from a comfortably “safe” distance from other users.

The physical distance between online users can create a false sense of safety and security. Although the risk may be extremely low, online interactions are not always free from real-world consequences. In some cases, a stranger could identify another user’s personal information, locate them, and attempt an in-person confrontation. This possibility highlights how the perceived anonymity and distance of online communication do not always guarantee personal safety.

Most people reasonably believe offline conflicts are unlikely to escalate into in-person confrontations.

The concept of the online disinhibition effect has something to do with this. Online, we feel “safer” to communicate things that we may not otherwise say to others in person.

Those things could be controversial or productive of conflict. In other words, we may start fights online with people we would avoid saying “fighting words” to in real life.

Likewise, those things could be vulnerable and “secret”. We may communicate things to an online stranger that we may not share with our closest in-person confidants. In some cases, this can have a positive effect on mental health, in that one feels unburdened of something.

Sure, people do this offline as well. Confession booths and conversations between strangers at bars lead to such behaviors.

But the idea behind the online disinhibition effect is that this lowering of one’s guard is common to internet usage. (You can read an influential paper on this phenomenon here.)

How Online Disinhibition Affects Mental Health and Relationships

Social media users may grow accustomed to sharing or seeing things they wouldn’t normally encounter or express offline. This habit can lead to decreased inhibition and potential problems in relationships or social settings.

Conversely, seeing other people get into conflicts online may make one fearful or anxious of fellow humans. (“Are other people really this aggressive? Judgmental? Prone to ostracization?”)

This can lead to excessive self-inhibition, making individuals feel unable to express their genuine thoughts or act naturally around others. Even in the company of close friends and family, they may hesitate to speak openly or behave authentically. This reluctance often stems from a fear of encountering aggression, criticism, or harsh judgment. Such fears may involve negative reactions from a single person or an entire group, ultimately limiting an individual’s ability to communicate freely and comfortably in social situations. Loneliness and its risks of mental health troubles can result.

Recent research suggests that emotion-regulation difficulties are associated with high online disinhibition, which in turn is associated with uncivil communication.

This brings us back to the potentially addictive nature of social media. Excessive use can contribute to problematic internet use (PIU), which researchers have linked to difficulties managing emotions. These challenges, known as emotional dysregulation, can make it harder to control emotional responses and cope with stressful situations.

Getting Help from Bonmente

This blog doesn’t cover all the ways social media affects mental health but aims to provide a clear overview.

Mental health conditions can be affected by using social networking sites, leading to worse mental health problems. 

If social media use is affecting your mental health, reach out to bonmente for support and guidance.

You may have deactivated your social media accounts or simply lowered your usage of a product or service. Long-term mental health challenges may improve with professional care.

We treat a wide range of psychiatric medical conditions that negatively affect people’s lives. We provide exceptional mental health care in California and Florida through in-person and telepsychiatry sesrvices.

Get well sooner

Don't spend another second wondering if life has to be this hard.
Find the help and support you need at bonmente.
Get started

Most relevant posts

Long Beach Mental Health, Telepsychiatry, Therapy
Long Beach Mental Health Services

Life in Long Beach, in Los Angeles, and in California in general comes with a unique set of stressors. But there’s help!